Case study
To be proved right
Non-payment of wages
As an EU citizen living in Germany, what can I do if I don’t receive my wages?
Case study
Dimitros was delighted when he found a job through an online advert with a subcontractor of a large logistics company. He is due to work as a courier and parcel delivery driver in Berlin. He has now been in the job for two months, but his enthusiasm is waning. Dimitros has not yet received any wages and has run out of money to live on. He has asked his boss about it several times. At first, he was told there had been a mistake in the accounts; his money had been transferred to another colleague by mistake. Then his boss told him that he himself was waiting for payment from the client. He could only pay Dimitros once he’d been paid himself. Recently, his boss has stopped answering the phone when Dimitros calls him. Dimitros doesn’t know what to do in this situation or which organisation he can turn to for help.
Who can help me get my wages?
1. job centre / Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit)
Dimitros has no money, and it may take some time for him to have his rights upheld. He should therefore apply immediately for unemployment benefit I at the local Employment Agency or for the Citizens’ Income at the local job centre.
Unemployment Benefit I
- Even if the employment relationship is still in force but the employer fails to pay the wages due, Dimitros can claim unemployment benefit I. In this case, the unemployment benefit acts as an advance payment against the employer’s obligation to pay. This is regulated in Section 157(3) of SGB III and is referred to as ‘equivalent provision’.
- If Dimitros worked in another EU country before taking up employment in Germany, any foreign contribution periods accrued during the qualifying period can be counted towards his entitlement to unemployment benefit in Germany.
- If Dimitros does not meet the eligibility criteria for unemployment benefit I, he can apply for the Citizen’s Income at the job centre.
Citizen’s Income
Dimitros can submit his application in writing or verbally. The job centre must provide him with the necessary application forms. Dimitros has a legal right to have his application accepted and assessed. Following the assessment, the authority must issue him with a written decision stating the reasons for its decision. Dimitros should expressly request this.
If Dimitros meets the eligibility criteria for the citizen’s income, he can also apply for an advance payment due to his difficult financial situation. This is advisable, as it often takes several weeks to process the application.
Arbeitsagentur.de – Find branch office addresses
2. Health insurance fund (Krankenkasse)
Dimitros should check with his health insurance fund to see whether his employer has registered him with social insurance and paid contributions on his behalf.
If the employer does not pay wages, they often fail to pay social security contributions as well. This results in gaps in health insurance cover. To find out, Dimitros must ask his health insurance fund.
If the employer has not registered Dimitros with social insurance, Dimitros should submit his employment contract and other employment documents to the health insurance fund (Krankenkasse). This will enable him to prove his employment. The health insurance fund acts as a collection agency (Einzugsstelle). It must close the gap in social insurance cover and claim the social security contributions from the employer.
3. Employers
Even though Dimitros has already raised his claims with his employer verbally, he should also write to his employer to demand his wages (demand for payment). Sometimes the employment contract even states that outstanding wages must be claimed in writing. Dimitros should set his employer a deadline for payment. He can draft the letter himself or with the help of an Advice centre.
In the letter, Dimitros can declare what is known as a ‘reservation of performance’. This means that he will refuse to work until he receives his wages. He is entitled to do so after two months of working without pay. Dimitros must also be paid for this period, even though he is not attending work.
4. Advice centre
At the advice centre, Dimitros is given information about his rights. The advisers can help him draw up a written demand for payment. Alternatively, they can contact his employer directly to sort out the matter.
Specialist employment law advice centres
Overview of all advice centres by specialism and language
Find a counselling centre
If the employer still fails to pay his wages, Dimitros will have to take them to the employment tribunal to get his money. In Germany, there is no authority that can claim the wages on his behalf. Dimitros must therefore take legal action himself.
5. Employment Tribunal
First, Dimitros must decide whether he wants to bring a claim before the employment tribunal with or without legal representation.
Bringing a claim without a solicitor
Dimitros does not necessarily need a solicitor at the employment tribunal; he can represent himself. The proceedings will take place at the employment tribunal in the place where Dimitros worked or where the employer’s company is based. Dimitros can decide this for himself.
The official language in court is German, so court officials are not permitted to speak to Dimitros in any other language. If Dimitros does not speak German well, he should be accompanied by someone who can help him communicate (‘language support’). This person does not have to be a sworn interpreter. A friend who speaks German well can help Dimitros.
Every labour court in Germany has a legal claims office where you can present all your documents (employment contract, timesheet, identity card) and explain your claim verbally. The claim will be drafted for Dimitros there. This is free of charge. However, the legal claims office is not permitted to give Dimitros legal advice. Directions to the legal claims offices and their opening hours can be found on the website of the relevant labour court.
Dimitros can also fill in the claim form and send it to the labour court by post or fax. The claim forms are available on the websites of many labour courts.
Once he has filed the claim, Dimitros will receive a written summons to a conciliation hearing. The purpose of this hearing is to find out whether Dimitros and his employer can reach an agreement. Dimitros may request the presence of an interpreter for this, but he will have to pay for this himself. In most cases, the proceedings before the employment tribunal are settled at this first hearing. In such a case, Dimitros would not incur any costs (apart from the interpreter’s fees).
If time is of the essence, Dimitros can claim his wages through summary proceedings in court. However, he must then demonstrate that he is in urgent need of the wages.
If the case is not complicated – as in Dimitros’s case – he can alternatively submit his claim through a written debt collection procedure. There is no oral hearing. The debt collection procedure concludes with an enforcement order. An enforcement order is equivalent to a court judgement.
Caution!
The form for the labour court order for payment procedure should not be confused with the form for the civil court order for payment procedure. The ‘order for payment’ form can be ordered online or bought from stationery shops. It costs around 3–5 euros and is very easy to complete.
Example of a payment order
Labour Court Order for Payment Form (not accessible) [PDF, 245 KB]
Dimitros must submit the completed form to the relevant employment tribunal.
If the employer does not lodge an objection to the order for payment, the court will send Dimitros the enforcement order, which directs the payment of his wages.
Legal proceedings with a solicitor
If Dimitros does not wish to appear before the employment tribunal on his own, he can be represented by a solicitor. He can find a solicitor through the embassy or via a recommendation from friends or acquaintances. The Bar Association’s websites also offer search functions that allow you to find solicitors with different language skills and areas of specialisation.
Search engine of the German Bar Association
In addition, an advice centre may also be able to help with finding a solicitor.
However, Dimitros must pay the lawyer’s fees himself. He will not be reimbursed for these costs even if he wins the case.
As Dimitros does not have the money to pay for a solicitor, he can apply for the state to cover these costs (‘legal aid’). To do so, certain conditions must be met:
- The claim must have a reasonable chance of success.
- Dimitros must prove that he cannot afford the legal costs himself.
- Furthermore, for a period of four years following the conclusion of the court proceedings, Dimitros is obliged to inform the court, without being asked and without delay, if his financial circumstances have improved.
If his financial situation improves significantly during this period, the court will order Dimitros to repay the costs! The application for legal aid is made using a form which can be obtained from the court or found online.
Sample form for legal aid
The application for legal aid must be completed and submitted in German. A translation of the application and guidance on how to complete it in several languages can be found on the Federal Office of Justice’s website.
Dimitros submits the application for legal aid to the employment tribunal. If the application is granted, the costs of the solicitor and the court fees will be covered.
If Dimitros is a member of a trade union, a trade union lawyer can represent him in court free of charge.
6. Notification Office/Commercial Register
Does the employment tribunal state that the employer’s whereabouts are unknown? In that case, Dimitros must provide the tribunal with the employer’s new address. He can contact the notification office (Meldestelle zur Sozialversicherung) or the commercial register to find out the new address.
At the notification office (Meldestelle zur Sozialversicherung), Dimitros will be given access to the register of residents if he states that he has filed a claim against his employer (on the form:
‘Purpose: Legal enforcement of wage claims’).
Application for information from the register of residents
Example form: Information from the Register of Residents (not accessible) [PDF, 266 KB]
If the company is listed in the commercial register, Dimitros can find the address via the commercial register. The commercial register is maintained by the local civil court; you can also submit a request for information online.
Application for information from the Commercial Register
Sample form: Commercial Register information (not accessible) [PDF, 171 KB]
If Dimitros is unable to obtain any information through these channels, he may apply to the employment tribunal to have the claim served by posting it publicly at the court.
Application for public service of process where the addressee’s whereabouts are unknown
Example form for public service of documents (not accessible) [PDF, 239 KB]
What is public service of process?
It may be the case that the employer has moved away. You do not know where he or she now lives. However, letters from the court must be sent to them in order for them to have legal effect. If you do not know their new address and cannot find it out, you can post the letter on the notice board at the court building. This serves as a substitute for sending it by post.
7. Magistrates’ Court
If the employer fails to pay voluntarily following a court judgement or settlement, Dimitros will contact a bailiff to initiate enforcement proceedings. The bailiff is assigned by the local magistrates’ court in the area where the employer is resident or has their place of business.
What is enforcement?
If there is a court judgement, the employer must comply with the terms of the judgement, for example by paying the wages. If the employer does not do this voluntarily, the decision is referred to a bailiff. The bailiff carries out enforcement proceedings: they search the employer’s premises for money and other valuables, which are then used to settle the employer’s debts.
Dimitros can find the address of the relevant local court online in the court directory.
8. Insolvency payment
In some cases, even the bailiff may be unable to recover the money:
- The employer closes down their organisation and relocates.
- The employer has already made a statutory declaration and ceased trading some time ago.
- The company has filed for insolvency.
In such cases, Dimitros’s wages are guaranteed for a maximum of 3 months by what is known as ‘insolvency pay’. He must submit an application to the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit) in the area where the employer is based within 2 months after the company has filed for insolvency registration.
What is insolvency pay?
If an employer has a lot of debt and can no longer pay their bills, they are insolvent. In this case, the Employment Agency pays compensation for the missing wages at the employees’ request – this is known as ‘insolvency pay’. Insolvency pay is paid for the last three months prior to the insolvency. Insolvency pay is also paid if the employer’s business is permanently closed down.
Dimitros can find the application form for the insolvency payment online on the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit)’s website.
9. Financial Control of Undeclared Work (Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit, FKS)
If an employer fails to pay wages, they are, for example, in breach of the Minimum Wage Act. This may make them liable to prosecution. Dimitros can therefore lodge a complaint with the local Financial Control of Undeclared Work (Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit, FKS). The Financial Control of Undeclared Work is a government body that monitors employers. It checks whether they pay the minimum wage and correctly pay social security contributions on behalf of their employees. The FKS in the region where Dimitros’s employer is registered is responsible for investigating his case.
Zoll.de – Find an office
Dimitros can contact the FKS in person to file a complaint and give a statement. However, he can also submit a report online.
Dimitros’s report may lead the FKS to investigate the matter. Whilst this will not help Dimitros to recover his wages, his employer may then be punished with a fine or a prison sentence for tax and social security fraud. To ensure the case is investigated and processed efficiently, the FKS needs as much information as possible. Dimitros should therefore provide details of the duration of his employment, his daily working hours, the amounts he received, and any witnesses.
As a rule, Dimitros should not suffer any disadvantages as a result of his employer’s failure to pay social security contributions. Any gaps in all branches of social security (pension, health, long-term care, unemployment and accident insurance) must be closed by the relevant insurance scheme once the circumstances come to light. Insurance cover remains in full force.
Further topics
minimum wage
Collective agreement wage
Short-time working
To be proved right
Case study