Case study
To be proved right
Working without a registered address
As an EU citizen, can I take up employment in Germany even though I do not yet have a registered address?
Case study
Ivan from Bulgaria has recently arrived in Berlin and is looking for work. He is staying with a friend for the time being. His friend is helping Ivan until he finds a flat of his own. Finding a flat is difficult, as Ivan does not yet have a job and therefore cannot provide proof of income. He cannot register his address with his friend’s landlord because the landlord has not authorised subletting. Ivan has tried to register as a jobseeker with the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit). However, he was turned away because he cannot provide registration proof. Ivan also wanted to open a bank account. He asked at several banks but was always turned down because he is not registered with the police. Through acquaintances, he was offered a job in a snack bar. However, the snack bar owner told Ivan that he is not allowed to employ him without a police registration. The owner also requires a tax identification number and a social security number (Sozialversicherungsnummer), which Ivan does not have. Ivan is at his wits’ end. On the internet, he has found a Bulgarian consultancy firm where you can buy a registered address for €100 a month. He is considering taking up the offer.
How Ivan can legally take up employment in Germany, even if he does not yet have a registered address:
1. With the employer
A purchased registered address is not a solution. This constitutes a false registration, which is an administrative offence. Ivan is therefore breaking the law if he provides this address to the authorities. Furthermore, he has no control over the delivery of important official correspondence, as he would never receive the post in person.
A registered address is not a prerequisite for taking up employment. The employer is therefore not entitled to demand a registration certificate from Ivan. It is sufficient for Ivan to provide the employer with a current address where he can be contacted, for example at his friend’s house.
If Ivan has difficulty convincing the snack bar owner of this, he can show him the factsheet published by the Berlin Advisory Centre for Migration and Decent Work in collaboration with the Berlin Senate Department for Integration, Labour and Social Affairs.
Employment without registration of a residential address for EU citizens
2. With the health insurance fund (Krankenkasse)
The employer may require Ivan to provide a certificate for registration with the health insurance fund (Krankenkasse) and his social security number (Sozialversicherungsnummer).
As Ivan has never been insured in Germany before, he must first choose a health insurance fund. The employer must then perform the registration process for him with that fund. A registered address is not required. Ivan only needs to provide a contact address, for example that of his friend (Ivan Surname, residing with Mr First Name Surname).
As soon as the employer registers Ivan with the health insurance fund (Krankenkasse), he is covered by social insurance through his employer. This includes
- pension insurance,
- accident insurance,
- long-term care insurance and
- unemployment insurance.
Ivan will then automatically be issued with a social security number (Sozialversicherungsnummer), which will be sent to him.
3. At the bank
Like anyone else legally resident in Germany, Ivan has the right to open a basic bank account. He must not be treated less favourably on the grounds of his nationality or place of residence. A registered address is not required to open the account.
With a basic account, you can
- cash deposits,
- withdrawals,
- direct debits and
- bank transfers
can be carried out.
Ivan simply needs to present his identity card or passport at the bank and provide a postal address. It is sufficient if he can be contacted via his friend. Ivan can use the account opening application form provided by the bank. There are also templates he can use.
Application to enter into a basic account agreement
He must complete the form himself or with the help of an Advice centre and submit it to the bank. Things move quickly from there: the bank has a maximum of 10 business days to open the account.
If the bank rejects his application, it must also inform him of this within 10 working days. Ivan can then contact the Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin) either on his own or with the help of an Advice centre. There, he can request that the bank’s decision be reviewed.
Application for administrative proceedings in the event of refusal to conclude a basic account agreement
If the decision to refuse was unfounded, the bank will be ordered to open the account and must do so. Ivan will receive written confirmation of this.
Alternatively, Ivan can also contact any anti-discrimination body. The anti-discrimination body can contact the bank and resolve the matter on Ivan’s behalf.
Federal Anti-Discrimination Agency
4. At the Tax Office
Ivan’s employer needs his tax identification number in order to access the ELStAM data (payroll tax deduction details) for the payslip.
What is ELStAM?
ELSTAM is the abbreviation for ‘Elektronische LohnSTeuerAbzugsMerkmale’ (electronic payroll tax deduction details). The tax is calculated electronically by the Tax Office. To do this, the Tax Office requires details such as tax category, tax allowances and church membership. This is known as ELSTAM data. This information is included in every payslip.
You can also view it online; to do so, you must register at www.elster.de (Online Tax Office).
As Ivan is not registered in Germany, the Tax Office will not automatically issue him with a tax identification number.
As a person liable for tax who is not registered in Germany but will be earning money here, Ivan must take the initiative himself and ask the relevant Tax Office for a tax identification number. The Tax Office will request this from the Federal Central Tax Office, which may take some time.
In the meantime, Ivan can apply to the Tax Office in his local area for a certificate for income tax deduction. This option is provided for in Section 39e(8), first sentence, of the Income Tax Act (EStG). The certificate is issued for one calendar year and, for the time being, replaces the tax identification number required by the employer.
Application for the issue of a certificate for income tax deduction
Ivan can complete the application for this certificate himself or with the help of an Advice centre. Ivan’s employer can also apply for the certificate on his behalf if Ivan authorises them to do so.
As soon as Ivan completes his registration with his own address, his tax identification number will be sent to him by post. He must provide this to his employer. Once this is done, Ivan will no longer need the provisional certificate.
If Ivan does not provide his employer with a certificate, the snack bar owner, as Ivan’s employer, must still calculate his wages for tax purposes. In this case, Ivan’s income will be taxed under tax category VI (Section 39c(1) of the Income Tax Act (EStG)). If too much income tax is deducted, Ivan can claim a refund the following year by submitting a tax return.
5. At the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit)
Ivan can register as a jobseeker with the Employment Agency (or Arbeitsagentur) even without a registered address. Ivan is entitled to do so because he has his habitual residence in Berlin. Although Ivan does not yet know how long he will be staying in Berlin, he plans to work and live here.
Ivan should contact the Employment Agency in the area where he is staying and spending the night, i.e. in the district where his friend’s flat is located.
Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit) – Contact persons
It is important that Ivan can be contacted by post, for example by adding details to his address (‘c/o’, ‘c/o Mr Surname’, etc.).
As an EU citizen, Ivan can use the services of the Employment Agency even without any knowledge of German. If Ivan explains that he cannot bring anyone along to translate for him, the Federal Employment Agency must arrange for translation, for example through its own staff or an interpreting helpline. Ivan does not have to pay anything for this.
Ivan can also register as a jobseeker online.
Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit) – Registration
The Jobcentre can help Ivan find work. It can advise him on how to navigate the job market effectively and help him create a CV. At the Federal Employment Agency’s Career Information Centre (BiZ), Ivan can use the computer stations to print out or scan his application documents.
6. At the Residents’ Registration Office
As soon as Ivan rents his own flat, he must complete registration. Under Section 27(2), sentence 3 of the Federal Registration Act (BMG), there is a notification obligation (Meldepflicht) even for people who otherwise have a registered address abroad.
After three months in Germany, Ivan must complete the registration of his flat with the Citizens’ Office or the Residents’ Registration Office within 14 days. A flat is defined as ‘any
enclosed space used for living or sleeping’ (Section 20 of the BMG).
Ivan can only assert many of the rights he is entitled to in Germany as a Union citizen entitled to free movement if he can provide credible evidence of his domicile and habitual residence in Germany by presenting a registration certificate.
Further topics
Residence of family members
Recognition of foreign qualifications
To be proved right
Case study