Article
Event
Integration of immigrants from South-Eastern Europe
On 29 November 2024, the Office for the Equal Treatment of EU Workers brought together representatives from politics, the civil service and the field to examine the current challenges and opportunities relating to the integration of immigrants from South-Eastern Europe.
Minister of State Alabali-Radovan is discussing with representatives from local authorities and the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit) how integration can be made more successful
EU-GS
Germany is one of the main destinations for migration from Europe, particularly from Romania and Bulgaria. Many migrants carry out essential work in sectors such as agriculture, meat processing and home care, but often face significant challenges, for example in accessing fair working conditions, affordable housing and healthcare. Local authorities also face challenges, particularly in relation to ‘derelict properties’, benefit fraud and additional responsibilities such as the rapid integration of migrants into schools and training systems, as well as the provision of language courses and integration measures. To tackle these complex challenges, the Office for the Equal Treatment of EU Workers organised a full-day exchange with mayors, city councillors, department heads, representatives from the advisory sector and the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit). The aim was to develop policy strategies and practical approaches to improve the integration of immigrants from South-Eastern Europe in the long term.
Morning: Round-table discussion at the Federal Chancellery
At the Federal Chancellery, Minister of State Reem Alabali-Radovan opened the event with a clear message: “Those who come to Germany to work usually arrive full of drive and hope. However, employees from South-Eastern Europe in particular often face difficult starting conditions – partly because dubious recruitment agencies and untrustworthy job adverts lure them with false promises. It is important that we speak openly about the opportunities and challenges. With a clear direction, without resentment.”
The subsequent discussion focused on the structural and social barriers faced by immigrants. Topics such as access to fair working conditions, affordable housing and healthcare took centre stage. Dr Gunilla Fincke from the Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs took stock of the last ten years, since the Committee of State Secretaries first met to discuss these issues. The challenges remain significant, but progress is being made: more and more local authorities and institutions are working on innovative solutions to promote integration.
Afternoon programme: Practical workshops
Following the discussion, the Office for the Equal Treatment of EU Workers (EU-GS) hosted a professional exchange. In parallel workshops, the nearly 80 participants discussed the key challenges and opportunities relating to integration.
Volker Meier, Head of the Task Force of the Federal Government Commissioner for Migration, Refugees and Integration, welcomes the participants at the specialist event.
EU-GS
Workshop 1: Making the target group visible to public authorities
Example project: City of Mannheim – Advice on initial registration
Challenge: The invisibility of EU citizens from South-Eastern Europe poses a significant challenge for German authorities. Many migrants accept offers from private employment agencies, which, in addition to job placement, also organise accommodation and transport. These individuals often find themselves in precarious employment situations and only come to the authorities’ attention when they contact the police or tax authorities due to exploitation.
Project description: In Mannheim, there is a pilot project designed to ensure that this target group is reached at an early stage. Two staff members from the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit) are based at the Citizens’ Office and offer multilingual advice in Romanian and Bulgarian. Anyone who completes a registration as a new resident in Mannheim is immediately offered advice on accessing the labour market and support services.
Conclusion: A personal approach at the initial point of contact has the potential to build trust and lay the foundations for long-term support. This measure helps to identify problems at an earlier stage and take preventive action.
Recommendation: It should be examined whether this model can be replicated in other towns to ensure broader support.
Further information:
Workshop 2: Access to the labour market and employment services
Example projects: City of Munich – Job Matching / Frankfurt
Airport Challenge: Many immigrants from South-Eastern Europe, due to fear of the authorities and language barriers, do not use official employment agencies but turn to private recruitment agencies instead. This significantly increases the risk of undeclared work (Schwarzarbeit) and labour exploitation. It is also notable that many workers in marginal employment (mini-jobs) are simultaneously receiving social security benefits.
Project description: Special projects have been launched in Munich and Frankfurt to place migrants in suitable jobs. Job fairs and placement appointments are organised, with interpreters present to overcome language barriers. Employers from the low-skilled labour market segment, including Frankfurt Airport, also take part in these events. Particularly noteworthy is the ongoing contact maintained after a successful placement, which helps to ensure sustainable integration.
Conclusion: The high level of participation and interest from the target group demonstrate the success of such measures. Maintaining contact with the placed employees is essential to ensuring long-term integration.
Recommendation: These projects should be extended to other sectors and regions to enhance their impact.
Workshop 3: Access to housing / Prevention of homelessness
Example project: Nostel Berlin
Challenge: Homelessness is a common problem amongst immigrants from South-Eastern Europe, particularly amongst families with children. Many emergency shelters lack adequate accommodation for families, which further exacerbates the problem.
Project description: The Nostel project in Berlin is specifically aimed at homeless families from the EU with minor children who are not entitled to benefits under SGB II or XII. Since 2014, it has been providing these families with temporary accommodation and close support. The aim is to integrate them into the labour market and to enable the children to attend school and nursery.
Conclusion: The combination of providing temporary accommodation and intensive support has proved effective.
Recommendation: More similar projects should be launched to strengthen cooperation between housing offices, social services and labour market stakeholders.
Further information: [Nostel Berlin]
Workshop 4: Access to the healthcare system
Example project: AOK Nordost
Challenge: Many migrants have gaps in their insurance periods as they have worked in different countries. These gaps often lead to high back payments upon joining the statutory health insurance (gesetzliche Krankenversicherung), which acts as a deterrent for many and encourages illegal employment.
Project description: AOK Nordost supports migrants by providing multilingual advice and assistance in clarifying their insurance periods. The aim is to avoid high debts and to facilitate access to statutory health insurance (gesetzliche Krankenversicherung).
Conclusion: Collaboration with statutory health insurance providers is crucial for overcoming obstacles at an early stage and promoting integration into the labour market.
Recommendation: Comprehensive information campaigns should be developed to educate the target group about their rights and obligations within the insurance system.
Workshop 5: Integration programmes
Example project: German language courses in Munich
Challenge: A lack of language skills is one of the biggest barriers to integration into the labour market. Many immigrants are unable to take up employment commensurate with their qualifications because they lack the necessary language skills.
Project description: In Munich, part-time language courses have been developed specifically for EU citizens who do not receive social security benefits. In addition, there are low-threshold language courses in integration cafés for homeless people. These measures are funded by the pilot project run by the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit) and the City of Munich.
Conclusion: These programmes not only facilitate integration into the labour market but also promote inclusion in society.
Recommendation: The expansion of job-specific language courses should be further pursued in order to promote qualifications in a targeted manner and facilitate access to skilled jobs.
Following the intensive work in the workshops, the EU Equal Treatment Office provided information on its multilingual information and advisory services, which support migrants and advisory organisations. Finally, the results from the workshops were presented in a plenary session.
Bettina Wagner introduces the audience to the information and advice services offered by the EU Equal Treatment Office
EU-GS
Overall conclusion: Strengthen innovative approaches – expand mutual exchange
The event clearly demonstrated that there are already many successful and innovative projects in place to promote the integration of immigrants from South-Eastern Europe. Exchange between local authorities was identified as a key factor for success. It was recommended that regular networking meetings and platforms be established to promote the transfer of knowledge between the stakeholders involved and to continuously develop the measures further.
Event
Article