Case study
To be proved right
Bogus self-employment
I work in Germany and am suddenly expected to work as a self-employed person rather than as an employee.
Case study
Ricardo, from Italy, works as a plasterboard fitter. Following a trial period, his boss tells him that he can now only be employed ‘on a self-employed basis’. The business has already undergone registration. However, nothing changes in his day-to-day work: he continues to work fixed hours, receives instructions from his boss and is supervised. When he falls ill, he also discovers that he is no longer covered by health insurance. Friends point out to him that his employment situation could be problematic. He wants to know what rights he has and who he can turn to.
What ‘bogus self-employment’ means
In a case of bogus self-employment, a person appears to be self-employed, but in reality works in the same way as an employee. For many workers from other EU countries, it is important to recognise this at an early stage. Entitlements to social insurance, continued pay in the event of illness, annual leave and other employment rights often depend on this.
1. Advice centres
In this case study, there is strong evidence to suggest that Ricardo is not genuinely self-employed. He works exclusively for one client, receives precise work instructions, follows the prescribed work processes and is not free to organise his work as he sees fit. Furthermore, the same work was previously carried out under an employment contract.
For an initial assessment, Ricardo can contact an Advice centre. There, he will receive information about his rights and the next steps to take. Many advice services are also available in other languages.
Advice
- BEMA – Berlin Advice Centre for Migration and Decent Work
- Arbeit und Leben – Advisory Network
- Faire Mobilität – Advice centres
- EU Equal Treatment Office’s advice centre search
An advice centre can offer support and information. However, it is other competent authorities that determine whether a case of bogus self-employment actually exists in legal terms.
2. Clearing House of the German Pension Insurance (Deutsche Rentenversicherung)
Ricardo can have his social security status checked by the German Pension Insurance (Deutsche Rentenversicherung) Clearing House. The Clearing House assesses whether a person should be classified as self-employed or as an employee.
Application for a determination of status
- Application for a determination of employee status by the German Pension Insurance (Deutsche Rentenversicherung) Clearing House
- Current list of clearing houses in Germany
The German Pension Insurance (Deutsche Rentenversicherung) Clearing House takes around four weeks to assess the status. Ricardo will then receive a written decision.
If the Clearing Centre confirms that Ricardo was in fact employed as an employee and not as a self-employed person, his employer must pay back all contributions (both the employer’s and the employee’s share of social insurance contributions) for all social insurance schemes, i.e. health, long-term care, unemployment and pension insurance. This is important, for example, for Ricardo’s entitlement to an old-age pension or unemployment benefit. The basis for calculating the contributions is the federal minimum wage.
3. Employment Tribunal
As a de facto employee who was only ostensibly self-employed, Ricardo had, from the start of his employment, all the rights of a ‘normal’ employee, namely the right to the statutory minimum wage and the right to continued payment of wages in the event of illness.
To assert his rights, Ricardo can bring a claim before the employment tribunal to have the employment relationship recognised. There, it can be clarified whether an employment relationship actually exists and what rights arise from it. Information on this procedure can be found in Chapter 2. In general, it is advisable to seek advice beforehand from one of the relevant Advice centres.
4. Health insurance fund (Krankenkasse)
As a result of registering his business, Ricardo was formally self-employed. For this reason, his employer may not have paid any health insurance or pension contributions on his behalf. If the clearing house later determines that he was engaged in bogus self-employment, this may also have implications for his health insurance. Contributions already paid may, under certain circumstances, be refunded.
5. Tax Office
Ricardo must declare his income to the Tax Office. Anyone who has completed a business registration is generally obliged to submit a tax return. Failure to do so on time may result in additional costs.
If it transpires that the employer has not correctly deducted tax on the wages actually paid, Ricardo should seek expert advice, for example from a tax adviser or a solicitor specialising in tax law.
6. Trade Office
If it is established that Ricardo was a pseudo-self-employed person, his business activities will cease. The business should then be subject to deregistration.
Deregistration of a business
7. Financial Control of Undeclared Work (Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit, FKS)
Bogus self-employment can have legal consequences. The Customs Authority’s Financial Control of Undeclared Work (Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit, FKS) checks, amongst other things, whether employers are paying social security contributions correctly. Ricardo can contact the relevant FKS office and explain his situation. Providing as much detail as possible is helpful for the investigation, for example regarding the duration of employment, working hours and pay.
Find the relevant office
Report a concern online
These rights apply to all employees in Germany – including workers from other EU countries. If you are unsure whether you are self-employed or actually an employee, you should contact an Advice centre at an early stage. There you will receive support, often in your native language.
To be proved right
Case study