Case study
To be proved right
Forced labour and labour exploitation in Germany
I work in Germany or would like to work here. That is why it is important to know my rights. No one should be forced to work or exploited at work.
Case study
Daniel, from Romania, finds work in Germany through an agency. He is required to pay 1,000 euros for the placement, which he is then expected to ‘work off’. Once in Germany, his employer withholds his papers and identity documents. Daniel works around twelve hours a day, six days a week. He receives no regular wages and is instead expected to repay alleged debts. When he tries to resign and get his documents back, he is threatened. He speaks hardly any German, is unaware of his rights and sees no way out of the situation.
Daniel’s situation shows typical signs of human trafficking, forced labour or labour exploitation. Labour exploitation occurs when people are forced to work under unfair and unlawful conditions. Forced labour occurs when people are kept in work through threats, deception or other forms of pressure and are unable to leave their jobs of their own free will.
A checklist from the Service Centre against Labour Exploitation, Forced Labour and Human Trafficking can help to identify such signs:
Service Centre: List of indicators (checklist of typical signs of labour exploitation and forced labour)
1. Specialist advice centres for victims of human trafficking and forced labour
Victims of forced labour have specific rights. German authorities are required to identify potential cases and protect people in situations of coercion. There is also a right to information and advice.
- For people like Daniel, it is important to contact a specialist Advice centre as early as possible. The advice service provides support with, amongst other things:
- questions regarding residence,
- questions regarding social security benefits (e.g. job centre, social security office),
- psychosocial counselling and crisis support,
- finding legal representation,
- medical care,
- finding accommodation.
This support is available to both employees from EU countries and people from non-EU countries. Many counselling services are multilingual or work with interpreters.
You can find an overview of specialist advice centres here:
- Advice centres against labour exploitation and forced labour (nationwide overview of specialist advice centres)
Labour law advice centres also frequently recognise signs of exploitation and can help with the next steps.
Further resources:
2. job centre
Daniel is an EU citizen and is therefore, in principle, entitled to free movement. Anyone affected by forced labour may, under certain conditions, be entitled to cost-of-living benefits under SGB II. Specialised advice centres can help assess potential entitlements.
For benefits to be granted, a certificate from the police, customs or the public prosecutor’s office is usually required. This confirms the suspicion of labour exploitation, forced labour or human trafficking, or sets out the relevant facts of the case. The Advice centre can help to obtain the necessary evidence.
3. Police/Customs
Those affected can contact the police or customs directly. However, it is often advisable to seek help from a specialist Advice centre first. Such centres are familiar with similar cases and can provide support when dealing with the authorities.
In Daniel’s case, his employment was not properly registered. Furthermore, no tax or social security contributions were paid in respect of his work. This is unlawful.
For victims of human trafficking or forced labour, the risk of being punished for such offences is often low. In certain cases, the public prosecutor’s office may decide not to prosecute, particularly if victims cooperate with the authorities and are key witnesses.
Although victims are not generally obliged to cooperate with the police or customs authorities, doing so can be helpful. It can help to clarify their own situation and prevent further exploitation.
4. Employer
Anyone who has worked is, in principle, entitled to the agreed wage or the wage required by law. This also applies to employees from other EU countries, such as Daniel.
Employment advice centres can help you claim any outstanding wages. They can assist you in contacting your employer and, if necessary, in finding legal representation.
Further information can be found in Chapter 2: Non-payment of wages
5. Court: Criminal proceedings / Civil claims in criminal proceedings
If criminal proceedings are brought against the employer, a specialist Advice centre can provide information on the possible steps to take and arrange for appropriate support. It can also help you find legal representation.
In addition, it can be assessed whether there are any claims for compensation. This may relate to financial losses, such as lost wages, or other consequences of exploitation.
If you recognise signs of forced labour or labour exploitation, you should seek help as soon as possible. Specialist advice centres can work with you to assess what rights you have and which organisation can provide support in your specific case. This applies to all employees in Germany – particularly to employees from other EU countries who are not yet fully aware of their rights here.
To be proved right
Case study