Case study
To be proved right
Short-time working
I work in Germany and my employer has temporarily reduced my working hours. As a result, I am now earning less than before. Here I can find out what the rules are and where I can get help.
Case study
Yuri has been working as a customer service representative for a tour operator for a year. Due to a sharp decline in bookings, his employer is introducing short-time working in order to keep Yuri in his job, at least for the time being. Yuri signs an agreement to this effect, even though it is worded unclearly. It states that he is to work between 0 and 40 hours per week. No duration for the short-time working is specified. In the months that follow, Juri works varying numbers of hours each month. Instead of his usual wage of 2,000 euros, Juri receives 1,200 euros per month. He does not understand his payslips. Then, after three months, he is made redundant on operational grounds. Juri feels that he has been underpaid. He wants to know what his rights are and where he can turn for help.
Yuri can seek help and support from various sources:
1. Advice centre
Yuri first contacts an advice centre for foreign employees. There, he receives support free of charge. The advisers often speak several languages. Advice is often available in his native language as well.
Employment law advice centres:
- https://www.bema.berlin/
- https://www.arbeitundleben.de/arbeitsfelder/beratungsnetzwerk
- https://www.faire-mobilitaet.de/beratungsstellen
The EU Equal Treatment Office provides an overview of further advice centres by topic and language:
- https://www.eu-gleichbehandlungsstelle.de/eugs-de/eu-buerger/beratungsstellensuche
The advice explains to Juri which rules apply to short-time working. Short-time working is intended to help prevent redundancies. Employers can temporarily reduce working hours if there is significantly less work.
In principle, employers need the consent of their employees to introduce short-time working. The agreement should clearly set out when short-time working begins and ends, by how much working hours are to be reduced, and for how long this is to apply. Juri has doubts as to whether these conditions have been met. It can therefore be checked whether he may be entitled to his full pay for the hours lost.
Employees receive short-time working allowance for lost working hours if the legal requirements are met and the employer has duly notified the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit) of the short-time working arrangement. The short-time working allowance is usually 60 per cent of the lost net wage; for employees with at least one child, it is 67 per cent. The employer receives a reimbursement for this from the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit).
During annual leave, the employer must, as a general rule, pay the normal holiday pay. Special rules also apply to public holidays: if a public holiday falls during a period when work would normally have taken place, short-time working must not result in a reduction in pay. The exact calculation can be explained by advice centres or a solicitor.
When comparing the time sheets with the payslips, the advisers realise that Juri has probably been underpaid. They advise him to have his wage entitlement checked and, if necessary, to claim back pay. Further information can be found in Chapter 2: Non-payment of wages.
Juri also learns that dismissal during short-time working is not automatically ruled out. As he has been working for more than six months in an organisation with more than ten employees, he is covered by general protection against dismissal. A labour court can determine whether the dismissal is lawful.
When the employment relationship ends, so does the short-time working arrangement. For the remaining period until the end of the notice period, there are specific pay entitlements, which are determined in accordance with employment law provisions and the agreed short-time working arrangements.
Important: Anyone who later applies for Unemployment Benefit I will not, in principle, face any disadvantages due to the short-time working. Unemployment benefit is calculated as if the hours worked had not been reduced. Short-time working alone therefore does not usually result in a lower assessment basis for Unemployment Benefit I.
2. Employment Tribunal
If Juri wishes to challenge his dismissal, he can bring a claim before the relevant employment tribunal.
As a rule, the labour court at the employer’s registered office has jurisdiction. If Juri worked in a different location, he can often bring a claim there as well.
He can find the relevant employment tribunal here:
The claim can be lodged via the court’s claims registration office. Many labour courts also provide forms on their websites. Advice centres can help with filling them in.
A template for a claim for protection against unfair dismissal is available for download:
Important: A claim for protection against unfair dismissal must, as a general rule, be lodged with the employment tribunal within three weeks of receiving the notice of dismissal. After that, it is usually no longer possible to bring a claim.
If the court finds that the notice of dismissal is invalid or socially unjustified, Juri can keep his job.
3. Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit)
The advice centre suspects that the information regarding working hours and short-time working allowance is incorrect. It therefore advises Juri to inform the Jobcentre and to provide supporting evidence, such as records of his working hours.
He can find the relevant office here:
Reporting this does not affect any entitlement to back pay. However, it may help to uncover any potential misuse of short-time working allowance.
If a criminal offence is suspected, the Job Centre may pass the information on to the public prosecutor’s office. The allegations will then be investigated and, if necessary, an investigation will be launched.
4. Financial Control of Undeclared Work (Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit, FKS)
In Juris’s case, it can also be investigated whether there have been any breaches of labour law or the Minimum Wage Act.
The Financial Control of Undeclared Work (Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit, FKS) is part of the customs service. Among other things, it checks whether employers are complying with legal requirements and paying social security contributions correctly.
Juri can find the relevant office here:
Juri can make a statement in person there or report the matter. It is also possible to submit information online:
If you have any questions about short-time working, wages, short-time working allowance or redundancy, you should seek advice at an early stage. This is particularly important if deadlines are approaching or if you suspect that your employer has underpaid you. There are numerous free advice services available in Germany for employees from other EU countries. Many advice centres offer multilingual services and can also provide advice in your native language.
To be proved right
Case study