Case study
To be proved right
Temporary work
I am working in Germany through a temporary employment agency, or I would like to take up such a job. It is important for me to know what rights I have in Germany as an EU citizen.
Case study
Marisa has been working for a temporary employment agency for one and a half years. Temporary agency work means that she is employed by a temporary employment agency but works for another company. Along with many other Portuguese workers, she is deployed at a logistics centre. Although her employment contract specifies a full-time position, the number of hours she works varies considerably. As a result, in some months she receives significantly less pay than expected. Furthermore, she is being asked to sign a termination agreement and will be rehired after three months. Marisa is worried about the implications for her unemployment benefit and does not know how to respond.
Marisa’s situation highlights typical problems associated with agency work. It is important for workers from other EU countries to know that specific rules and protective provisions apply to agency work, and that these also apply to them. The following organisations can offer assistance or are responsible for dealing with specific enquiries.
1. Employer
According to her employment contract, Marisa must be available to her employer for 40 working hours per week. Conversely, the temporary employment agency must, in principle, pay for these hours. If the employer temporarily has no assignment for her, she is still entitled to the agreed wage. This entitlement is often referred to as a guaranteed wage.
If the temporary employment agency only pays for the hours actually worked, even though a higher number of working hours had been agreed, this may breach obligations under employment law. In principle, she must claim the outstanding pay herself. Employment law advice centres can provide support with this. Advice is often available in various languages.
Advice and support
- Berlin Advice Centre for Migration and Decent Work (BEMA)
- Arbeit und Leben – Advisory Network
- Fair Mobility – Advice centres
- EU Equal Treatment Office’s advice centre search
Information on enforcing wage claims can also be found in Chapter 2, ‘Non-payment of wages’.
Marisa should not sign the termination agreement too hastily. After 18 months’ work with the same hirer, permanent employment may be an option under certain conditions. Furthermore, a termination agreement entered into voluntarily may have adverse effects on her entitlement to unemployment benefit.
2. Works council of the lending organisation or the borrowing organisation
A works council is the body elected by employees to represent their interests within the organisation. It supports employees when they face problems at work.
If there is no works council at the temporary employment agency, Marisa can also contact the works council at the logistics company. This works council is the point of contact, particularly for issues such as working hours, health and safety, or working conditions. The logistics company has a duty of care towards the temporary workers it employs and can intervene with the temporary employment agency if problems come to light.
3. Arbitration bodies affiliated with trade unions
Many temporary employment agencies are members of the Gesamtverband der Personaldienstleister e. V. (GVP), which was formed in December 2023 following the merger of the German Temporary Work Agencies’ Association (iGZ) and the Federal Employers’ Association of Personnel Service Providers (BAP). The GVP requires its members to adhere to certain rules and standards, which are set out in the association’s Code of Conduct and Ethics.
If the temporary employment agency is a member of the GVP, the employee may contact the independent contact and arbitration body:
Contact and Mediation Office (KuSS)
Email: kontakt@kuss-zeitarbeit.de
Telephone: 030 25762847
Website: www.kuss-zeitarbeit.de
Alternatively, a written complaint may be addressed directly to the association:
General Association of Personnel Service Providers e. V. (GVP)
Berlin Office
Universitätsstr. 2−3a
10117 Berlin
info@personaldienstleister.de
4. Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit)
The supply of temporary agency workers is governed by the Act on Temporary Agency Work (AÜG). In Germany, the Act on Temporary Agency Work regulates the supply of temporary agency workers (temporary agency work) to other companies.
Breaches of these rules can be reported to the relevant Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit).
Marisa can lodge a complaint with the Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit) and explain her case. It is important to provide as much detail as possible, along with supporting evidence, such as an employment contract or payslips.
Advice centres can help with preparing a complaint. If breaches of the Act on Temporary Agency Work (AÜG) are found, fines or further regulatory measures may be imposed on the temporary employment agency.
The Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit) grants licences for the supply of temporary agency workers. The local jurisdiction of the relevant ANUE departments is determined by the registered office of the temporary work agency:
- Düsseldorf Employment Agency
- Jurisdiction: North Rhine-Westphalia, Hesse
- Email: Duesseldorf.091-ANUE@arbeitsagentur.de
- Nuremberg Employment Agency
- Jurisdiction: Bavaria, Baden-Württemberg, Rhineland-Palatinate, Saarland
- Email: Nuernberg.091-ANUE@arbeitsagentur.de
- Kiel Employment Agency
- Area of responsibility: Bremen, Hamburg, Berlin, Brandenburg, Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, Lower Saxony, Saxony, Saxony-Anhalt, Schleswig-Holstein, Thuringia
- Email: Kiel.091-ANUE@arbeitsagentur.de
5. Financial Control of Undeclared Work (Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit, FKS)
Across Germany, the main customs offices are responsible for combating undeclared work (Schwarzarbeit) and illegal employment through their Financial Control of Undeclared Work (Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit, FKS) departments. They accept reports – including anonymous ones – and investigate breaches of the Act on Temporary Agency Work as well as labour and social security legislation.
The relevant main customs office can be identified using the office locator on the Customs website:
Alternatively, a report can be submitted directly via the online contact form:
For general enquiries, please contact the General Customs Directorate’s Central Enquiries Office:
General
Customs Directorate Central Enquiries
PO Box 10 00 61
01077 Dresden
6. Borrower
The hirer is the company where the work is actually carried out. In Marisa’s case, this is the logistics centre.
If she is assigned to the same organisation for longer than 18 months, this may have significant legal consequences. Under the provisions of the Act on Temporary Agency Work, an employment relationship with the hirer may arise under certain conditions.
Important: Following a permanent appointment, certain time limits start running again. For example, general statutory protection against dismissal with the new employer generally only comes into effect after six months. Previous periods of employment with the temporary work agency are not taken into account.
Anyone working through a temporary employment agency who is experiencing problems with pay, working hours or a planned termination of contract should seek advice at an early stage. Employees from other EU countries are covered by the same labour law protections as other employees in Germany. Many advice centres also offer support in various languages.
To be proved right
Case study