Case study
To be proved right
Undeclared work (Schwarzarbeit)
I work in Germany and receive my wages – but I’m not sure whether my employment is properly registered. I may not have been given an employment contract, I don’t receive payslips, or I don’t know whether I’m covered by health insurance.
Case study
Dona Victoria is from Romania and works in a meat processing plant in Germany. An agent promised her a job, accommodation and 1,500 euros a month. Although she does receive her wages in cash on a regular basis, she has no written employment contract and no payslips. She has not been given any information about health insurance either. She does not know whether she is insured or whether she can see a doctor. She is therefore wondering whether her employment is legal and which organisations can help her.
What ‘undeclared work’ means
If employees do not receive an employment contract or do not know whether they have been registered with social insurance, this may be an indication of undeclared work (Schwarzarbeit). Undeclared work (Schwarzarbeit) occurs when statutory obligations towards social insurance or the Tax Office are not met. The following organisations can help you clarify your status and assert your entitlements. This information is particularly important for workers from other EU countries who are not yet fully aware of their rights in Germany.
1. Employer
Employers must confirm the key terms and conditions of employment in writing. These include, in particular, pay, working hours and the names and addresses of the contracting parties. This information must be provided in writing by the first day of work at the latest.
The fact that Dona Victoria has not received a written employment contract does not automatically mean that she is being employed illegally. The decisive factor is whether her employer has performed the registration for social insurance and is paying the required contributions.
With a net wage of 1,500 euros, the gross wage is approximately 2,082.87 euros. Social security contributions must be calculated and paid from this amount.
The absence of an employment contract and the payment of wages in cash may be indications that the employment has not been properly registered. Dona Victoria should therefore ask her employer for the following documents:
- a written employment contract,
- the social insurance registration,
- details of the competent health insurance fund.
Employers must carry out registration of employees with social insurance no later than six weeks after they start work. Registration is carried out via the health insurance fund (Krankenkasse). Employees generally have the right to choose their own health insurance fund.
These rights apply to all employees in Germany – including workers from other EU countries.
2. Health insurance fund (Krankenkasse)
Once they have completed registration, employees receive a health insurance card. This enables them to access medical services.
If Dona Victoria does not receive an insurance card, she should contact her health insurance fund to check whether she has undergone registration. Specialist advice centres for migrants offer support. Advice is often available in languages other than German.
You can find an advice centre in your area here:
- Find an advice centre
If she has not been granted registration, Dona Victoria can choose a statutory health insurance fund herself and inform them of her employment.
The website offers a detailed comparison and a list of German health insurance funds in German and English:
Before making a choice, she should find out about the benefits, advisory services and any offers available in her native language.
If she can prove that she has actually worked, the health insurance fund must assess how the gap in insurance coverage for the period of employment can be addressed. It is important to provide details of the start date of employment, the wages received and any other available evidence of employment.
3. Subcontractors
If it transpires that no social security contributions have been paid, in certain sectors the company for which the work is actually carried out may also be held liable.
In the meat processing sector, as well as in parts of the construction, parcel and courier sectors, the principle of ‘subcontractor liability’ applies. This means that the contracting company may be obliged to pay outstanding social security contributions if the direct employer has failed to do so.
In the case of Dona Victoria, therefore, the meat processing plant may also play a role.
Specialised advice centres offer support:
- BEMA Advisory Centre for Migration and Decent Work
- ‘Arbeit und Leben’ Advice Network
- Fair Mobility – Advice centres
Further advice services by topic and language:
- Find an advice centre
Outside the sectors mentioned, this specific liability often does not apply. In such cases, it may be necessary to make a claim directly against the employer.
4. Tax Office
Employers must also perform employee registration for tax purposes and pay income tax to the Tax Office.
Dona Victoria can check with the relevant Tax Office to see whether the employee has been registered for registration. If no income tax has been paid, a back payment may be required. The calculation is based on the gross salary, not the net salary paid out.
5. Financial Control of Undeclared Work (Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit, FKS)
The Financial Control of Undeclared Work (Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit, FKS) is a customs authority. Among other things, it checks whether employers are paying social security contributions and taxes correctly.
If Dona Victoria suspects that her employer has not conducted the registration for her, she can contact the relevant FKS office. In principle, the office responsible is the one at the company’s registered office. If this is not known, she should contact the FKS office at her place of work.
Find an office:
A report can also be made online:
It is helpful to provide as much detail as possible, for example:
- Duration of employment,
- working hours,
- Amount of payments received,
- any documents available,
- potential witnesses.
The FKS can launch investigations and impose penalties for breaches.
It is important to note that, in Dona Victoria’s case, if she was unaware of the failure to report these matters, she would not normally face any criminal consequences for the evaded social security contributions.
Employees should not suffer any disadvantages if their employers fail to make proper registrations. If it comes to light that registrations are missing, the relevant authorities must examine how the gaps in insurance cover can be closed. Anyone who is unsure should contact an advice centre at an early stage. This applies in particular to employees from other EU countries, who are often not fully aware of their rights in Germany. Advice is frequently available in their native language as well.
To be proved right
Case study